September 10, 2010

HOME / Motorcycle / Yamaha FZ16 vs TVS Apache RTR FI

Price point

Similarly priced? Oh yes. Similar bikes? Oh no. We unravel the RTRFI vs FZ16 riddle
del.co
digg
                                      
Engine and performance
Let's get refinement out of the way first. The Yamaha is, by miles, the more refined engine. The RTRFI is astonishingly throaty, but the Yamaha is quietly gruff as well. But it's in the vibration department that the Yamaha creams the TVS.

But on the performance front, there is not contest. Yamaha always intended for the FZ to be a torquey street bike and it shows. Get to 7,500rpm and the game's up. There isn't much power left. Cruise the torque and the FZ is remarkably quick through traffic and will hold a nice 80kph cruise down the highway. You could sit for aeons on the throttle and get a much higher top speed in theory, but it's a waste of time. The TVS, though, aims for glory. The motor is as gung ho as a horny rooster in a fecund henhouse and it wastes no time letting you know this. From idle, the motor urges you to keep revving ever harder. And it rewards you with, first, loads of torque and then with a headrush of small cube horsepower. 15.5PS is a lot to ask from such a small motor, but the TVS is genuinely fast.

Essentially, while comparable on price and displacement, these two motorcycles are night and day in feel. The Yamaha is competent, calm and classy. The TVS is urgent, powerful and sassy. Pick the character that you like more, and you'll be happy.

Want numerical evidence? Check out the table. You will notice that the RTR is half-second quicker to 60, nearly 3.50 seconds quicker to 100, 0.9 seconds quicker over the quarter mile, 7kph quicker at the top. And, ridden steadily, It also returns nearly 13kpl more than the Yamaha.

Performance
Comparison

0-60kmph
(seconds)

0-100kmph
(seconds)
 0-400m
(seconds)
Top Speed
(kmph)
Fuel Economy
(kmpl)
Kerb Weight
(kg)
 TVSApache RTRFI
4.73
15.07
18.9
114.0
62.9
139
 Yamaha FZ16
 5.20 18.5019.8106.748.1126


Score FZ 0 FI 1

Tags:

  Yamaha FZ16 FZ Fazer TVS Apache RTR FI RTRFI 160 150 premium commuter comparison

Comment on "Price point"

Comment

Name

 

City

 

Email Address

 

Word above:

60 Comments
sabyasachi
Mar 10, 2009
10:20 AM
Hey wats the result did it becamed draw
Vijayendra Vikram Singh
Mar 10, 2009
01:54 PM
Apache rtr's got it's share of flaws but then when it comes to outright performance it's the king. Fz's more balanced and you can never go wrong with it. Gives u the kicks, but is a little stressd out at the top.
Shubhabrata Marmar
Mar 10, 2009
01:55 PM
No, it isn't a draw. My personal winner is the fz16.

but anyone who wants performance and performance alone, will be happier with the rtr fi.
Math
Mar 10, 2009
04:41 PM
Fz has come from yamaha that’s why every one got hesitation to say the truth. Why they can’t say fz is the complete winner? They can’t bcos fz lags in performance, top speed, and fuel efficiency also. But still they are telling fz is better than fi . . . !

fz has a fantastic look and style nothing else.
Prashant Rajput
Mar 10, 2009
07:07 PM
Apache is an outright performance bike which was launched to compete with the current performance kings of bajaj (the pulsar).
it has taken them head on and succeeded to a great extent where as fz is a smooth operator from yamaha after the hugely successful rx series.
kapil
Mar 10, 2009
09:28 PM
When will new model of karizma going to come , i m just fred up of watching these sticker changes
gautam
Mar 11, 2009
09:41 PM
Yamaha fz16 rulesss!!!!!
New Stories

ADVERTISING

MOST POPULAR
MOST COMMENTED
Latest News